Short List
Haley Lawless (4)
Mitch Nay (2)
Micsha Carson--Track & Field (1)
Kara Linder--Fencing (1)
Patrick Murphy (1)
Derrick Richardson--Football (1)
Keri Suell--Track & Field (1)
Number in parentheses is how many cycles the finalist has been on the short list (not counting the 2020 cycle in which the induction ceremony was cancelled due to COVID-19).